About Us

Best Insurance Agency Inc. in Butler Pa, can trace its roots to 1917, when Wesley Sipe and Carroll Miller formed Sipe Miller Company. In 1951, J. Alvin Magill became partner and the agency was renamed Miller Magill Agency. At the death of Carroll Miller, Elmer E. Best became a partner in Miller-Magill-Best Agency. Upon the death of Magill in 1973, Elmer Best became the sole owner of the Best Agency.

Best Insurance Agency and its predecessors have never been located more than 1 – 1/2 blocks from the present location on South Main Street, in Butler Pa, which speaks to our commitment to Butler and to our valued clients.

Present owners, employees, and length of service include Donald Best, since 1979, Carol Best McClean, 1971, Richard McClean, 1973, Michael Reese and Ray Rosenbauer, 1993, Catherine Berger-Reese, 1996, Jamie McDonald, 1997, Thomas Fleming, 1998, Carol Prokay, Michelle Warner, since 2001, and Katie Peindl, 2002.

We represent a wide range of insurance, which allows us to find the combination of coverage and right price for you. We pride ourselves on our fast, friendly service and attention to detail.

Whether you are someone looking for home insurance, business insurance or auto insurance in Butler Pa, our experienced professional staff can help you with all your needs.